What do I do if a customer threatens a bad review?

Published 19 November 20263 minute read

The short answer

Stay calm, listen, and fix what's fair, the same as any complaint. Don't offer money or a discount to stop the review, and don't tell them not to post one. If a stranger demands money to stop bad reviews, report it to Google as extortion.

"Fix it or I'll leave a bad review." It feels like a threat. Most of the time it's a complaint with a sharp edge. Treat it like a complaint. This is general information, not legal advice.

Listen first

I learned this the hard way on sales calls. My first couple of calls were atrocious, because I was trying to force a prospect down a track. You should actually have two ears and follow their problem.

Same here. Let them finish. Write down what they say went wrong. Take the criticism as feedback, even if it stings. Don't argue the review. Talk about the job.

Want to see how your reviews and replies look to the next customer? Get your Free 3R check.

Fix what's fair

If they're right, say so and fix it. That's what you'd do anyway. A problem fixed well is often what turns an angry customer around.

If they're not right, explain calmly what you did and why. Offer to discuss it on the phone. As the business owner, your response sets the tone.

What you must not do

  • Don't offer money, a discount or a free job to stop the review. Google's policy does not allow incentives in exchange for posting a review or the "removal of a negative review".
  • Don't tell them not to post one. Google's policy does not allow a business to "discourage or prohibit negative reviews".
  • Don't threaten them back. Stay polite, even if they don't.

What the ACCC says

The ACCC says a business may mislead consumers if it tries to "suppress or edit negative reviews" or "remove genuine reviews that are negative."

So the fix is the job, not the review.

If they leave the review anyway

Reply calmly, the next day. Thank them, own the part that's fair, and offer to sort it out by phone. See How do I respond to a bad Google review?

If the review isn't true, the ACCC says a business can respond "to correct the public record." Stick to the facts.

If it's a stranger, not a customer

Some people aren't customers at all. They post a run of bad reviews, then ask for money to take them down. Google calls this an extortion scam.

Google says: "Do not engage with or pay the malicious individuals." "Do not try to resolve it yourself by offering money or services." "Gather all evidence immediately." Then report it with Google's merchant extortion report form. See What do I do about a fake Google review?

Keep notes

Write down what was said, when, and by whom. Keep the texts and emails. If it goes further, you'll be glad you did.

The whole picture is on our Reputation page.

This is general information, not legal advice. If a dispute is serious, get your own advice.

What this means for your business

  • Treat a threat like a complaint: listen and fix what's fair.
  • Never pay or offer a discount to stop a review.
  • Never tell a customer not to post one.
  • If a stranger demands money, don't pay. Report it to Google.

Read next

How do I respond to a bad Google review?

Wait until you are calm, then thank them, own the part that is fair, and offer to sort it out by phone. What to write, what never to write, and what to do if it is fake.

Frequently asked questions

Can I offer a refund if a customer agrees not to leave a bad review?
No. Google's policy does not allow incentives in exchange for removing a negative review or discouraging one. Fix the problem on its merits.
Can I ask a customer not to leave a bad review?
No. Google's policy does not allow a business to discourage or prohibit negative reviews.
What if someone demands money to remove bad reviews?
Don't pay or engage. Gather the evidence and report it with Google's merchant extortion report form.
Can I reply to a review that isn't true?
Yes. The ACCC says a business can respond to correct the public record. Stay calm and stick to the facts.
Is this legal advice?
No. It's general information from Google's policies and the ACCC's guidance.
How should I respond to a bad customer review?
Wait until you're calm. Thank them, own the part that's fair, and offer to sort it out by phone. Our answer on responding to a bad Google review has the words.

Your listing and your customers stay yours.

Everything stays yours.

Your Google listing, your website and your customer list are yours, always.

Questions about billing?

Ask us before you start.

Free 3R check