What do I do about a fake Google review?

Published 13 November 20263 minute read

The short answer

Report it to Google from your Business Profile, then reply calmly in public. You can't delete it yourself. Google checks the report, and if it says no, you get one appeal.

A one-star review from someone you've never met stings. Don't fire back. The next customer is reading, and they want to see how you handle it.

Is it really fake?

Check your job records before you flag anything. It may be a fake review if:

  • You can't find the customer anywhere in your bookings, quotes or invoices.
  • It talks about a service you don't offer, or a place you don't work. Google's review policy says reviews must be based on a real experience, so off-topic reviews can be reported.
  • It comes with a sudden run of one and two-star reviews in a short time.
  • It reads like it came from a competitor. Google's policy does not allow posting on a competitor's business to undermine it.

Worried a few bad reviews are costing you calls? See how you look next to the businesses near you. Get your Free 3R check.

Report it to Google

  • Open your Google Business Profile and go to your reviews. Select the review.
  • Choose to report it (some people call it flagging a review), then pick the reason that fits, like spam.
  • Keep a note of why you think it's fake, like no record of the customer.
  • Google says "review evaluation typically takes several days." You can check where it's up to in the Reviews Management Tool.

Reply calmly while you wait

Your reply is public. Write it for the next customer, not the reviewer.

Example reply: "We can't find a record of this job. Please give us a call so we can look into it."

Don't accuse anyone. Don't argue. A calm owner reads well. An angry one doesn't.

If Google says no

Google says if a flagged review doesn't qualify for removal, you can "submit a one-time appeal". You can include up to 10 reviews in one appeal.

If it still stays, leave your calm reply there and move on. See Can I delete a bad Google review?

If someone asks for money to take reviews down

That's an extortion scam. Google says it usually looks like "a sudden increase in 1-star and 2-star reviews", then "someone demanding money, goods, or services in exchange for removing the negative reviews."

Google's advice: "Do not engage with or pay the malicious individuals." "Gather all evidence immediately." Then use Google's merchant extortion report form. See What do I do if a customer threatens a bad review?

Don't fight fake with fake

Some owners try to bury a fake review with good ones from friends. Don't. The ACCC says it's against the law for a business to create fake or misleading reviews or to arrange for others to do so.

The honest way to make one bad review matter less is a steady stream of real ones. Ask every customer, every time. The whole system is on our Reputation page.

What this means for your business

  • Check your records before you decide a review is fake.
  • Report it from your Business Profile, and reply calmly while Google checks.
  • If Google says no, you get one appeal.
  • Never pay anyone to remove reviews, and never post fake ones back.

Read next

Can I delete a bad Google review?

No. A business cannot delete a Google review. What Google will remove, how to report a review, how to appeal, and what the ACCC says.

Frequently asked questions

Can I delete a fake Google review?
No. Only Google can remove a review. Report it from your Business Profile and Google decides.
How long does Google take to check a reported review?
Google says review evaluation typically takes several days. You can check the status in the Reviews Management Tool.
Should I reply to a fake review?
Yes, calmly. Say you can't find a record of the job and ask them to call. Don't accuse anyone.
What if someone wants money to remove bad reviews?
Don't pay or engage. Gather the evidence and report it with Google's merchant extortion report form.
Can I ask friends to leave good reviews to balance it out?
No. The ACCC says it's against the law for a business to create fake reviews or arrange for others to.
Does reporting a Google review remove it?
Only if Google finds it breaks its policies. If it doesn't qualify for removal, you can send a one-time appeal from the Reviews Management Tool.
How do I appeal a fake review decision on Google?
Use the Reviews Management Tool. Google allows a one-time appeal, with up to 10 reviews in one appeal.

Your listing and your customers stay yours.

Everything stays yours.

Your Google listing, your website and your customer list are yours, always.

Questions about billing?

Ask us before you start.

Free 3R check