How do I catch up to a competitor with more Google reviews?

Published 16 November 20263 minute read

The short answer

You don't need to match their total. Ask every customer, every time, and reply to every review. Recent reviews with replies show a customer you're busy and paying attention right now, even next to a bigger number.

Owners often say "my reviews are fine." Fine compared to who? The guy in your town with 200?

Work out the real gap

Search for your main service and your suburb, the way a customer would. Look at the businesses Google shows. For each one, write down:

  • How many reviews they have.
  • Their star rating.
  • The date of their most recent review.
  • Whether they reply to their reviews.

Want the gap worked out for you, next to the businesses a customer would compare you with? Get your Free 3R check.

The number isn't the whole story

A business profile with 200 reviews and nothing new this year looks like it's slowing down. A business with 40 reviews, and five from this month, looks busy now.

Replies matter too. A page where the owner answers every review looks cared for. See How many Google reviews does a business need?

Don't try to catch up overnight

  • Don't buy reviews. The ACCC says it's against the law for a business to create fake or misleading reviews or to arrange for others to do so.
  • Don't ask family or staff. Google's policy does not allow reviews from people with a conflict of interest.
  • Don't offer discounts. Google bans incentives for reviews.

Ask every customer, every time

This is the steady way to get new reviews. Ask as the job finishes. Text the link the same day. Use the same words for everyone. See What should I say when I ask a customer for a review?

Google says "more reviews and positive ratings can help your business's local ranking." Nobody can promise how fast. But a steady flow beats a burst.

Don't forget past customers

You've probably got customers from the last year who were never asked. You can ask them too, the same way, with nothing offered. If you text or email them, the Spam Act can apply, including the rules on consent and opting out. See Can I text or email my past customers in Australia?

Reply to every review, starting today

This is the quickest win. If your competitor doesn't reply and you do, potential customers reading both profiles notice. Reply to negative reviews calmly too.

Go back and reply to your old reviews too. A late reply still shows you read them. The whole system is on our Reputation page.

What this means for your business

  • Look at their count, rating, latest review and replies, not just the total.
  • Ask every customer, every time, with nothing offered.
  • Ask past customers the same way, and follow the Spam Act.
  • Reply to every review, including the old ones.

Read next

How many Google reviews does a business need?

There is no magic number. What matters is having more reviews than the businesses you are compared to, some recent ones, and a reply under every one.

Frequently asked questions

How do I get more reviews than my competitor?
Ask every customer, every time, and reply to every review. A steady flow of recent reviews beats a burst.
Do I need more reviews than them to rank higher?
Google says more reviews and positive ratings can help local ranking, but nobody can promise a result. Recent reviews and replies also help customers choose you.
Can I ask past customers for reviews?
Yes, the same way you ask everyone, with nothing offered. If you text or email them, check the Spam Act rules on consent and opting out first.
Can I buy reviews to catch up?
No. The ACCC says it's against the law for a business to create fake or misleading reviews or arrange for others to.
Why does my competitor have more Google reviews than me?
Usually because they ask more often, or they've been asking for longer. Look at how recent their reviews are, not just the total.

Your listing and your customers stay yours.

Everything stays yours.

Your Google listing, your website and your customer list are yours, always.

Questions about billing?

Ask us before you start.

Free 3R check