Do it yourself, review software, or done for you: which is right for me?

Published 20 November 20263 minute read

The short answer

If you'll really ask every customer and reply every week, doing it yourself costs nothing. If you'll do the replies but forget the asking, software helps. If you won't get to either, have it done for you. Pick the one you'll actually keep doing.

There's no single right answer for review management. It depends on how much time you've got, and how honest you are with yourself about what you'll keep doing. Here's a fair look at each, for a small business in Australia.

The three ways, side by side

Do it yourselfReview softwareDone for you
What you doAsk every customer, send the link, reply to every reviewLoad your customers in, write and send the repliesVery little. Someone else asks and replies
What it costsYour timeA monthly fee, plus your timeA monthly fee
Good forOwners with a few jobs a day and a steady routineBusinesses with an office person who can run itOwners who are flat out on the job
Watch out forIt slips when you get busyPaying for software nobody usesReplies that don't sound like you

Not sure which way suits you? See where your reviews stand first. Get your Free 3R check.

Do it yourself

It's free, and it works if you stick to it. Ask as the job finishes. Text the link. Reply to every review once a week.

The catch is busy weeks. That's when it stops, and busy weeks are full of customers you could have asked. The how-to is in How do I get more Google reviews for my business?

Review software

Review management software, or a review platform, can send the requests, remind people and show new reviews in one place. Some add monitoring of other review sites. You or someone in the office still writes the replies and keeps it running.

It suits a business with an office person. It doesn't suit an owner who'll log in once and forget the password.

Done for you

Someone else sends every review request and responds to every review, in your name. You check the hard ones, like a negative review. Some online reputation management firms also sell SEO and marketing. You don't need all that to look after your Google reviews.

Many of the businesses I've worked with had three to five trucks, not twenty. When the owner is the one on the tools, done for you is often the one that actually gets done.

As I say, selling AI is easy. What matters is the system behind it, and whether the work gets done every week.

What to check before you pay anyone

  • Do they ask every customer? If a tool only sends happy customers to Google, that's review gating. Google's policy does not allow it.
  • Do they offer customers anything for a review? Google bans incentives for reviews.
  • Who writes the replies, and do they sound like you?
  • Do you see bad reviews before anyone replies?
  • Is there a lock-in contract?

How to choose

Be honest. Look at the last three months. Did you ask every customer? Did you reply to every review? If yes, keep doing it yourself. If not, pick the option that takes the job off your list.

The rest of the reviews picture is on our Reputation page.

What this means for your business

  • Doing it yourself costs nothing, if you'll keep it up.
  • Software suits businesses with someone to run it.
  • Done for you suits owners who are flat out on the job.
  • Whatever you pick, check it asks every customer and offers nothing for reviews.

Read next

How do I get more Google reviews for my business?

Ask every customer the same way as the job finishes, and send your review link the same day. The words to use and the shortcuts that break Google's rules.

Frequently asked questions

What's the cheapest way to manage Google reviews?
Doing it yourself. It costs your time, not money, and it works if you ask every customer and reply every week.
Is review software worth it?
If someone in your business will run it every week, it can help. If nobody will, it's money for nothing.
What does done for you mean?
Someone else asks every customer for a review and replies to every review in your name. You check the hard ones.
What should I check before I pay for review help?
That it asks every customer, offers nothing for reviews, writes replies that sound like you, and shows you bad reviews first.
What is online reputation management?
Looking after what people read about your business online. For most service businesses, that mostly means Google reviews: asking every customer, and replying to every review.

Your listing and your customers stay yours.

Everything stays yours.

Your Google listing, your website and your customer list are yours, always.

Questions about billing?

Ask us before you start.

Free 3R check